Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Journal #8 - The End of an Era

So it wasn’t really an era, but the semester has ended. The Showcase was today. I did a few last minute tweaks yesterday but didn’t add or subtract anything today. Even though there weren’t lots of people present, I think it was a good crowd. I had seven people come by and check out Semantic Gradients. I think that was a great way to pilot test. And I’m glad I was present to watch and/or guide the user experience. That gave much more feedback than I think just a survey could provide.

Everyone’s feedback/reactions were different, but there were a couple that gave me ideas for improvement. It’s interesting – most of the changes they suggested or implied through their questions are things I’d thought about but decided not to push because of time. Suggestions included:
  • adding an audio option for the onscreen text of the main site
  • adding music to the second animation
  • removing a semi-redundant frame from the second animation
  • including a “hint button” for the “do it yourself” labels
  • providing another visual representation of a completed gradient
  • adding a vertical line as a guide to line up the labels

One question posed after the interactive movie was “how do you know if you’re right?” Well, that’s a fair question, but once again, this was not a game. This was a tutorial with a hands-on component to practice. It’s not designed to be used in classrooms – it’s designed to teach you a strategy that you can use. Normally teachers would read about a strategy and have no opportunity to practice, so this improves that to some degree.

I’m not sure how to provide “feedback” unless the words are pre-selected. Otherwise, working with a partner and using resources is the only way to “check” your work for an “open-ended” activity such as this. This is a drawback when people are expecting the “game” atmosphere. I’ll have to figure out a way to make it clear. I don’t know another solution.

In all it was a great experience – designing and developing. I truly felt as though I was problem-solving at all times. At each point, I had to reflect on where I was, converse with materials, decide how each solution would impact the design and then act (Gal, 1996). One of the reasons I chose IT as a major is because of my abiding interest in multimedia development. In a past life I wanted to create educational games. I’ve kind of gotten away from that – namely because I don’t want to “research” them, which is more the focus of a PhD program. But I will continue to factor in design and development work in my future.

References
  • Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Journal #7 - Accessibility and Other Touches

We are coming to the end of this semester. It seems weird to refer to it that way, as it’s only been a month since we started. At any rate, the Showcase is tomorrow. I was done with the major aspects of my project by my self-imposed Sunday evening deadline. Yesterday and today were reserved for the finishing touches. Among those finishing touches – accessibility.

Though I’ve done some designing in the past, it hasn’t been since widespread attention has been given to accessibility. Says Rose and Meyer, (2002) we needn’t feel pressured about the diversity of today’s learners – rather we should use what we know about diverse learners and create more flexible curricula and tools that can benefit everyone. Learning to make digital items more accessible has been a great opportunity to challenge my thinking in this area. I was familiar with some of the html options such as labeling ALT tags. But I really had no clue what I would do when it came to Flash. There was a small section in our textbook about it, and I followed the directions to make each of my movies accessible. See my picture below:



I also found a great white paper on accessibility in Flash and I found it very helpful. “By default, text objects in a Flash movie are read by screen readers. Screen readers are also able to identify buttons and movie clips with attached scripts. Screen readers cannot look at a graphic element on the screen and determine its meaning” (Regan, 2005, p. 8). I actually don’t have very many graphic elements outside of buttons attached to scripts. I have a plain background, which is for decoration, but doesn’t have a meaning attached. I also have the teacher, who appears throughout the site and in both demos. She is also decorative and adds visual interest, but she doesn’t impact the functionality. It’s a good thing too, because repeated attempts to “name” her in the accessibility options were unsuccessful.

Though I made the whole movie accessible, I still tried to label all individual objects. Unfortunately, the Action Script tried to read them and it broke the whole animation. So I deleted the tags, stopped trying to name the teacher, and left the “whole movie” accessible.
In addition to accessibility, other final touches included adding credits. It didn’t take long to add a screen for them. I gave credit to Feral Martian, the illustrator who designed the Modern Teacher graphic. It’s something I wouldn’t have thought to include if it hadn’t been for early desk crits to liven things up a bit. I also gave credit to Chris Williams, a friend of mine who produces music, for the demo soundtrack. Lastly, kudos were due to Maggie, who really helped me negotiate the twists and turns of Action Script.

Tomorrow is the big day! The final entry is due after the Showcase is over.

References

  • Chapter 4 of Rose, D.H. & Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching every student in the digital age: Universal design for learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
  • Development.[On-line]. Available: http://www.cast.org/teachingeverystudent/ideas/tes/Regan B. (2005). Best practices for Accessible Flash Design. Adobe Systems Incorporated. [On-line]. Available: http://www.adobe.com/resources/accessibility/best_practices/bp_fp.html

Sunday, June 29, 2008

Journal #6 - Iterative Intentionality

“In a design environment, knowledge is generated, enacted, and reflected on in an ongoing process between the materials and the participants’ intentions and attached meanings” (Gal, 1996, p. 226).


This quote is so reflective of my experiences thus far. I have made major progress with my Flash module. I went from my original idea, to an expanded idea, which then shrunk, and expanded again! Originally I only knew I wanted to create a tutorial. Over time, I realized I needed to make it interactive if possible. However, once I had my first conversation with the materials (Gal, 1996), I didn’t feel competent enough to go beyond my initial thoughts.

With help from a more experienced other (Maggie), I was able to go beyond my limited abilities, toward my expanded intentions. Working with Maggie, in my Zone of Proximal Development (Vygotsky, 1934/1986), I was able to accomplish much more than I thought I could, but that which was within the realm of my imagination.

It has truly been an iterative process – designing/problem solving, developing, reviewing, reflecting, and then tackling the new problems. Because I’ve been having such a great time, I decided to challenge myself and change my boring “one pager” html site into a Flash site. I decided to view some of the Blue Sock winners from the past – specifically viewing summer projects as I felt they would be much more realistic. No matter what, 16 days is nothing like 16 weeks, even if you are taking fewer classes in the summer. At any rate, some of those projects were still pretty involved, but it gave me more to aim for – hence, my decision to develop the website. See the pictures comparing the old and the new sites.






In Aldrich’s (2004) podcast he asked, “How do you make the interface a core part of learning the content? How do you take finite actions and turn them into an interface?” Those are fair questions, and challenging ones. It’s what I asked myself as I worked on Gradient2, the practice-oriented module. My focus wasn’t on content in the traditional sense, but I did want the interface to allow users to practice this strategy. It isn’t really a game, and I’ve not thought of a way at this point to make it more “game-like.” I try to take some consolation in the fact that teachers are busy people, and want a quick, engaging way to learn something new.
All in all it’s been great so far. I’m curious to see how dress rehearsal goes and what tweaks I’ll need to make for Wednesday.

References

  • Aldrich, C. 2004. Simulations and the future of learning. Presentation made at the 2004 Accelerating Change conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail372.html
  • Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.
  • Vygotsky, L. S. (1986). Thought and language MIT Press Cambridge, Mass.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Journal #5 - Phase Two

Phase Two is “on and popping,” as we say in Black Southern slang. I have made semi-great progress thus far. I have chosen the colors and symbols, and have arranged everything on the time line. I even attempted a little Action Script. That’s why it’s just “semi-great” progress – my Action Script isn’t working properly. For some reason, when I have more than two consecutive frames linked by a “next” button, one gets skipped. But as soon as I do only two, it works perfectly. I’m also having some trouble with the drag and drop code. I was able to trouble shoot that a little bit today before retiring, but it’s not 100% just yet.


Because I needed a little more face-to-face support with Phase Two, I went back to Phase One. I added start and stop buttons to that movie, and published the .html file in time for “Virtual Sharing.” I would also like to add sound on and off buttons, but I had trouble with those. Firstly, because I have an entire song aligned to the “visual” aspect of my movie. If you decide the turn the sound off and then back on again, it starts from the beginning which extends the length of the movie. I need it to start from where it is on the timeline. So more troubleshooting awaits me.

Though I’m having trouble, I don’t mind it at all. My past experiences with development work prepared me for the long road ahead, and because I like problem-solving, I find it easy to get into a “flow” state. In this state you’re working at an optimal level of challenge and enjoyment and time passes without your conscious awareness (Csikszentmihalyi, 1990). Kind of the opposite of my two-hour long stats class this summer. After the first hour I become aware of every passing second!

Seriously, learning to use the tools through building has been a great way to promote learner engagement. Says Dickey of engaged learning spaces (2005), “the learner plays an active role in the construction of knowledge, while the role of the teacher is to provide materials and an environment that support the learner’s engagement in the learning tasks…” (p. 78). This is definitely the way the Studio is designed. I appreciate it because it allows me to structure my time in the way that’s most beneficial for me. In this particular case, I can work as far as I can, totally engaged in the process, then get help when I get stuck. Hopefully, tomorrow I’ll get over these humps and be well on my way to completion!

References:

  • Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990). Flow: The psychology of optimal experience New York: Harper & Row.
  • Dickey, M. D. (2005). Engaging by design: How engagement strategies in popular computer and video games can inform instructional design. Educational Technology Research & Development, 53(2), 67-83.

Monday, June 23, 2008

Journal #4 - Phase One Done

Wow! So I’ve finished a draft of my first Flash movie. I’m very proud of it. I learned quite a bit during the process and found myself coming back repeatedly to the whole idea of constructionism – learning through building (Clinton & Rieber, 2006; Papert, 1996). Let’s take, for instance, animations. I did quite a bit of “tweening” in this project. What I didn’t realize was that each item needed to be on its own layer. I think I remember learning that “in the book,” but it wasn’t until I tried tweening multiple things at once that I realized the necessity of layering. In short, my animation didn’t work on the first try. But once I added the layers, it worked just fine. Built it – learned it.


I decided that it needed music along with the funky colors to make it more engaging. I used a clip my friend created – which is really cheery and upbeat. It definitely adds to the emotional design (Norman, 2004). People just feel good watching it. At least I do.

But now it’s on to phase two. I’m really doubting I’ll have enough time to complete another step of my project. I’m starting on it beginning today. This will be the interactive part – which of course is most important, yet most time-consuming. I’m also planning to add some action script. Nothing to fear, but this is what will make it a truly long process – at least based on my previous experiences learning to code.

This strategy (semantic gradients), is a cool one because it forces a deeper level of thinking. This is what I’m trying to capture through the second movie…the whole idea of trying it yourself, and seeing the thought involved. I showed Part 1 to David and we immediately launched into a conversation about some of the word choices featured. We had debate, each viewing multiple sources to get a more precise – nuanced understanding the words in question. This, I think, is the beauty of this strategy. By nature, it’s just designed to engage learners away from “memorizing” words, and toward really learning and appreciating the words. As Clark (2004) said, the point is not to know something, the point is to do something more intelligently. With respect to vocabulary, it’s not to memorize the words, it’s to apply them more intelligently. In the case of teachers, it’s not to teach students a list of words, it’s to teach them “more intelligent” ways to learn for themselves.

But this theory doesn’t just apply to content, it applies to my designing as well. My point is not just to memorize Flash, but find ways to use it intelligently to solve design problems. In this case, the problem of introducing teachers to a strategy that will help students think.

References:

  • Aldrich, Clark. 2004. Simulations and the future of learning. Presentation made at the 2004 Accelerating Change conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail372.html
  • Clinton, G., & Rieber, L.P. (2006). The Studio Experience at the University of Georgia: An example of constructionist learning for adults. Unpublished manuscript.
  • Norman, D. 2004. Emotional design: Presentation made at the 2004 O'Reilly Emerging Technology conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail69.html
  • Papert, S., (1996). A word for learning. In Y. Kafai & M. Resnick (Eds.), Constructionism in practice: Designing, thinking, and learning in a digital world (pp. 9-24). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Journal #3 - Conversations with Tools

I had envisioned how my Flash module would look – pretty simple actually. It was to be a tutorial after all – not a game, not anything too fancy. I got feedback via desk crits to liven it up a little, perhaps using graphics or whatnot. I was open to that, but didn’t have a new picture in mind. Unlike Clay, I couldn't use pirates in my module. And unlike Kathryn, there was no clear theme about food or anything else for that mater. A classroom would be appropriate, but how much visual interest would that really add?

I went to the istockphotography.com site where David found his graphic. I didn’t see lots of useful graphics, but I did see one or two that suddenly gave me some ideas. I especially like this one image called “modern teacher.” She’s black and white, but maybe I can add color. I’m not an artist, so I’ll pretty much have to use the graphic “as is”, but I’m excited that I have this new perspective. This conversation with tools (Gal, 1996) really did make a difference for me. I had limited my conversation to just “talking with” Flash and Dreamweaver. But looking through these graphics expanded what I thought was possible. I was limiting myself to my own (current) skillset, so as a result, I was limiting my project.

Said Rowland (1993), design is about solving problems that may not be clearly structured. Specifically, you design to create something of practical use. In my case, I am building a module to teach people a quick vocabulary strategy. There isn’t a single way to do that, nor a specific way it has to look. I had some ideas going in, but the ideas you start with don’t have to be the ones you end with.

At this point I’m worried about time. I’ll begin actually building my module today. I know how time-consuming development can be. While I really want to build in an interactive component, I’m not sure I’ll be able to pull it off in the less than two weeks we have remaining. While I really do want to make my project engaging, I have to realize that might be something I have to sacrifice in this short session.

References:

  • Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.
  • Rowland, G. (1993). Designing and instructional design. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41, 79-91.

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

Journal #2 - Problem Solving

I’m still learning Flash. So far so good. I should be done with the book in the next few days. I decided not to move forward with the rapid prototyping until I finish with the book. While I think my project will be relatively simple, I still want to know the basics of the bells and whistles before I get into designing.

This course is interesting because we are both designing and developing. I’ve done plenty of development work over the years – usually creating something as a result of someone else’s design or vision. I never really considered myself a designer though – even when it was my vision I was bringing to life.

I am beginning to realize that even in the midst of my development projects, I was designing. Gal (1996) offered a great rock climbing analogy, suggesting that rock climbers, like designers, don’t have a sure and steady path. They know the task, but have to make decisions based on all the information and resources (no matter how limited) at hand. Later in that same work he talks about how designers sometimes design by having a conversation with the materials. I think I am doing or will do both of those things – make design decisions and converse with materials in the midst of developing. It’s almost the only way forward when you’re not an expert using the tools required of you.

Now that I think about it, design is really about problem solving. Many times in the past I would find myself with a clear visual of what I wanted to create, but stuck either due to lack of knowledge or lack of resources. I would have to problem-solve - usually quickly as I was usually on a deadline. I was a rock-climber and didn’t even know it! I was certainly a problem-solver more than anything else, and I’m sure another person in my shoes would have made different decisions (better or worse, but different all the same).

My problem right now is trying to make the most of my project in a limited amount of time with a limited skill set. I’m more and more convinced about the need for interactivity to promote engagement (Papert, 1996). It will add time to my development process, but will probably be the most useful in making sure teachers “learn” the strategy. Papert’s article hit very close to home with references related to Critical Theory – namely critical thinking. He argues we don’t teach kids to think, we just teach them information. An old claim, yet still true today and perhaps of more import because the amount of knowledge available expands exponentially - daily.

I agree with him – you have to learn how to learn – how to construct your own knowledge. This vocabulary strategy won’t teach educators how to learn, but hopefully it will expose them to other ways of thinking about words and what they can do with words.

References:

  • Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.
  • Papert, S., (1996). A word for learning. In Y. Kafai & M. Resnick (Eds.), Constructionism in practice: Designing, thinking, and learning in a digital world (pp. 9-24). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Journal #1 - Intro, Layout & Colors

Many teachers, looking for ways to improve student achievement, turn to the Internet and other electronic sources. I am working with a school district’s Director of Literacy to create an electronic clearinghouse of literacy resources for her teachers. Once students master decoding, comprehension and vocabulary are often two big chunks teachers begin to focus on. Vocabulary is my focus for this course.

The clearinghouse will include a brief description of individual vocabulary strategies, research-based rationale to support their use, and an in-depth explanation of how to implement each one. “One-pagers” we call them to emphasize their brevity. I thought adding audio, video or other media would be a great way to really help teachers grasp the strategies.

I plan to create a Flash module that will quickly introduce teachers to a one of these vocabulary strategies – semantic gradients. Semantic gradients (also known as linear arrays), encourage word consciousness and vocabulary expansion as students grapple with commonly overused and underused words, and learn to make more precise language choices. I like it because it moves students away from “skill and drill” vocabulary instruction, and into more constructivist and even constructionist lessons. The students have to generate and manipulate words, which promotes the internal activity of building and/or deepening their knowledge, while creating and discussing an external artifact (Clinton & Rieber, 2006).

Right now my focus is on the “look” of the module. Since I’m a visual person, I have to “see” the end (or at least the middle) before I begin. It will probably be a single web page (one-pager), with a flash movie embedded. I’m trying to decide between a self-running module or an interactive module. Of course the interactivity will make it take longer - the whole strategy will take only seconds to see uninterrupted. But, “a constructivist teacher is not interested in the quickest learning if this means that learning will remain shallow and decontextualized” (Clinton & Rieber, 2006, p. 27). And we really do want the teachers to “get it.”

I want to do both – show the strategy in its entirety, and then include a second module where users can input their own words and try the strategy themselves. That may require more time than I have for this course. We’ll see.

Enough about the layout. Let’s talk about color. I’m in the mood to choose bright, cheery colors – a new departure for me, as I’m normally a neutral, low-key person. But I’m a little nervous about making it too fanciful because this strategy spans elementary school and middle school. Conventional wisdom tells us that elementary teachers love bright and cheery things, but middle school teachers want things more serious. Also, I’m a little partial to hot pink lately – something that might be okay for some people, but would turn off many females, and most males or more “serious” teachers. This is an important consideration. Norman (2004) warns that getting the technology right is only part of the problem. Designers have to win the hearts of their users. I’m not sure how many hearts would be attracted to a bright pink module.

I guess the next step is to stop thinking and start prototyping.

Activities to be completed soon:

  • Determine a color palette or two
  • Create a test page using Dreamweaver
  • Develop a few icons with Fireworks
  • Sketch a storyboard for the module
  • Determine what “bells and whistles” I’ll include

References:

  • Allen, J. (1999). Words, words, words: Teaching vocabulary in grades 4-12. Portland, ME: Stenhouse Publishers.
  • Beck, I. L., McKeown, M. G., & Kucan, L. (2002). Bringing words to life: Robust vocabulary instruction. New York: The Guilford Press.
  • Clinton, G., & Rieber, L.P. (2006). The Studio Experience at the University of Georgia: An example of constructionist learning for adults. Unpublished manuscript.
  • Norman, D. 2004. Emotional design: Presentation made at the 2004 O'Reilly Emerging Technology conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail69.html