Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Journal #8 - The End of an Era

So it wasn’t really an era, but the semester has ended. The Showcase was today. I did a few last minute tweaks yesterday but didn’t add or subtract anything today. Even though there weren’t lots of people present, I think it was a good crowd. I had seven people come by and check out Semantic Gradients. I think that was a great way to pilot test. And I’m glad I was present to watch and/or guide the user experience. That gave much more feedback than I think just a survey could provide.

Everyone’s feedback/reactions were different, but there were a couple that gave me ideas for improvement. It’s interesting – most of the changes they suggested or implied through their questions are things I’d thought about but decided not to push because of time. Suggestions included:
  • adding an audio option for the onscreen text of the main site
  • adding music to the second animation
  • removing a semi-redundant frame from the second animation
  • including a “hint button” for the “do it yourself” labels
  • providing another visual representation of a completed gradient
  • adding a vertical line as a guide to line up the labels

One question posed after the interactive movie was “how do you know if you’re right?” Well, that’s a fair question, but once again, this was not a game. This was a tutorial with a hands-on component to practice. It’s not designed to be used in classrooms – it’s designed to teach you a strategy that you can use. Normally teachers would read about a strategy and have no opportunity to practice, so this improves that to some degree.

I’m not sure how to provide “feedback” unless the words are pre-selected. Otherwise, working with a partner and using resources is the only way to “check” your work for an “open-ended” activity such as this. This is a drawback when people are expecting the “game” atmosphere. I’ll have to figure out a way to make it clear. I don’t know another solution.

In all it was a great experience – designing and developing. I truly felt as though I was problem-solving at all times. At each point, I had to reflect on where I was, converse with materials, decide how each solution would impact the design and then act (Gal, 1996). One of the reasons I chose IT as a major is because of my abiding interest in multimedia development. In a past life I wanted to create educational games. I’ve kind of gotten away from that – namely because I don’t want to “research” them, which is more the focus of a PhD program. But I will continue to factor in design and development work in my future.

References
  • Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Journal #7 - Accessibility and Other Touches

We are coming to the end of this semester. It seems weird to refer to it that way, as it’s only been a month since we started. At any rate, the Showcase is tomorrow. I was done with the major aspects of my project by my self-imposed Sunday evening deadline. Yesterday and today were reserved for the finishing touches. Among those finishing touches – accessibility.

Though I’ve done some designing in the past, it hasn’t been since widespread attention has been given to accessibility. Says Rose and Meyer, (2002) we needn’t feel pressured about the diversity of today’s learners – rather we should use what we know about diverse learners and create more flexible curricula and tools that can benefit everyone. Learning to make digital items more accessible has been a great opportunity to challenge my thinking in this area. I was familiar with some of the html options such as labeling ALT tags. But I really had no clue what I would do when it came to Flash. There was a small section in our textbook about it, and I followed the directions to make each of my movies accessible. See my picture below:



I also found a great white paper on accessibility in Flash and I found it very helpful. “By default, text objects in a Flash movie are read by screen readers. Screen readers are also able to identify buttons and movie clips with attached scripts. Screen readers cannot look at a graphic element on the screen and determine its meaning” (Regan, 2005, p. 8). I actually don’t have very many graphic elements outside of buttons attached to scripts. I have a plain background, which is for decoration, but doesn’t have a meaning attached. I also have the teacher, who appears throughout the site and in both demos. She is also decorative and adds visual interest, but she doesn’t impact the functionality. It’s a good thing too, because repeated attempts to “name” her in the accessibility options were unsuccessful.

Though I made the whole movie accessible, I still tried to label all individual objects. Unfortunately, the Action Script tried to read them and it broke the whole animation. So I deleted the tags, stopped trying to name the teacher, and left the “whole movie” accessible.
In addition to accessibility, other final touches included adding credits. It didn’t take long to add a screen for them. I gave credit to Feral Martian, the illustrator who designed the Modern Teacher graphic. It’s something I wouldn’t have thought to include if it hadn’t been for early desk crits to liven things up a bit. I also gave credit to Chris Williams, a friend of mine who produces music, for the demo soundtrack. Lastly, kudos were due to Maggie, who really helped me negotiate the twists and turns of Action Script.

Tomorrow is the big day! The final entry is due after the Showcase is over.

References

  • Chapter 4 of Rose, D.H. & Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching every student in the digital age: Universal design for learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
  • Development.[On-line]. Available: http://www.cast.org/teachingeverystudent/ideas/tes/Regan B. (2005). Best practices for Accessible Flash Design. Adobe Systems Incorporated. [On-line]. Available: http://www.adobe.com/resources/accessibility/best_practices/bp_fp.html